[19]
SOFT PLASTIC BAITS AND OTHER LURES
I have a feeling that
when we get to grips with the practicalities of fishing with big soft plastic
lure we will catch a lot of pike on them. I know that there have been people using
smaller bass-sized plastics for many years, with success, but as with all bass
lures they are way too small for pike. Either that or they are not the right sort
of shapes. Long slim worms and snakes are not as likely to appeal to a pike as
a nice chunky slug or grub. That's my thinking anyway. The
biggest problem with soft plastics is that they are mostly intended to be rigged
on single hooks, usually just one. This means that a pike has to hit the head
end of the lure or engulf the whole thing if you are to hook it. My introduction
to plastics was with Mister Twistser's Slimy Slugs in the six inch size. In my
first hour and a quarter fishing these slugs I had ten takes, landing just one
fish. Now I admit that most of the pike that hit the slugs were under two pounds,
and so had trouble getting them in their mouths, but what was obvious from the
slashed state of the tail ends of the baits was that the pike were hitting them
towards the rear. Because I was rigging the baits to be weedless with the hook
point only just showing, hooking problems were compounded. Switching to a weedless
hook, at Dave Scarff's suggestion, helped matters and the hook up rate improved
slightly. I am not alone in suffering this annoyance. One angler I spoke to had
adopted the policy of feeding slack as soon as he felt a take, only striking when
the line started to move - a little bit like when wobbling a deadbait. This takes
quick reactions and patience, but is something I am sure any serious lure angler
can learn with practice. Fishing with soft plastics is nothing like using hardbaits
and will require a total re-think for U.K. anglers to fully come to terms with.
For fishing in open water then I suggest adding a treble hook stinger to the large
single. Since using the six inch slugs, I have got hold of some of the original
soft plastic slugs from Lunker City (a company not a place!), Slug-Go in the nine
inch size. These are far more of a mouthful and are even more effective in my
opinion, and a lot easier to cast. However, they also suffer from the problem
of pike hitting the tail end. Although
these slugs look like nothing much on earth they have an incredible action in
the water when fished like a jerkbait. The hook makes the front half of the bait
rigid, and should be rigged in such a way that the slug is perfectly straight.
If there is even a slight bend in the bait it will spin, and if the nose is kinked
up or down it will work too high, or dive respectively. Rigged true the slug becomes
a totally unpredictable jerkbait, but with a twitching tail. After much repeated
casting slugs can 'ball up' on the cast. This can be prevented by a drop of superglue,
or by pegging the bait to the hook with a piece of wooden cocktail stick or something
similar pushed through the bait and the eye of the hook. With
practice, and a light trace, slugs can be walked on the surface, which really
does draw pike up. I have even had takes skipping them over weed so the lure actually
left the water as it hopped along. By allowing them to sink they are fished much
like jerkbaits but have to be worked slower to maintain depth. There are insert
weights available, to make the slugs heavier and let them be fished faster or
deeper. Insert weights look like headless nails made of lead, which can be trimmed
to give just the sink rate that you require. Not surprisingly the addition of
an insert weight makes a Slug-Go cast even more easily. Exactly where in the slug
you place these weights will give differing actions to the lure.
A nine-inch Slug-Go, fished just sub-surface, lured this late summer fish.
One
answer to the hook up failure rate might be to rig the slugs on a trace with a
couple of trebles. This would be fine if putting a hook close to the tail of the
bait didn't completely kill the action. Because Slug-Gos can be rigged to be almost
completely weedless, with just the tip of the hook point exposed, additional trebles
will prevent you using the baits to fish where no lure has gone before! With the
hook point inside the bait slugs can be cast into thick cover and brought back
free of weed. I can't say that this has caught me stacks of pike, but the odd
one has come from in the lily pads. The secret of the pike attracting success
of slugs is undoubtedly the tail action coupled with the where-next darting. At
times when fishing close to the surface a Slug-Go will jump out of the water for
no earthly reason! As with jerkbaits, this unpredictable action probably explains
part of the problem with hooking the pike. At the other extreme there are times
when pike will slam these slugs and hook themselves. Slugs
can be fished fast, with quick-fire twitches of the rod tip, but when fished dead-slow
they give a whole new dimension to what is known as finesse fishing. This technique
is usually associated with light tackle and small lures, but in my book nine inch
Slug-Gos are finesse baits. They make little disturbance as they hit the water,
and even less as you fish them, they don't attract by violent actions or noisy
rattles. Although slugs can have a lively action when being worked pike will take
them on the drop - when they have no action at all! When allowing a slug, or any
other soft plastic, to free fall watch the line for unexpected movements, and
treat them as takes. Indeed, I would class all soft plastic baits as finesse lures
for the simple reason that they don't make a lot of commotion. Maybe "stealth
lures" would be a better name for them?
Unlike slugs, grubs and twister-tails need a weighted jig hook to be fished, to
maintain their stability. If you can get hold of grubs in sizes of six inches
or longer then you will catch pike on them. Guaranteed. The hardest part is getting
jig heads big enough. Jigs from «oz upwards with hooks of 3/0 or larger,
even up to 8/0, are what you need. Hooks with a good wide gape, too, and the longer
the shank the better. A wide gape and a long shank keep the hook point away from
the lead head, which can otherwise mask the hook when you try to drive it home. Rigging
grubs on a jig is just like adding one as a trailer to a spinnerbait. I like to
get the hook to exit the grub just in front of the curly tail, right at the end
of the body. If this means trimming the grub to size, then so be it. Lay the jig
alongside the grub before rigging it to gauge the exact spot, and maybe work out
where to trim the bait to. Fishing grubs is simplicity itself. While they can
be jigged along the bottom, a sure fire way of finding snags in my experience,
they also work on a straight retrieve. The rippling tail is fantastically fishy.
For some reason I have had no great problems connecting with pike on these lures,
they just hit them hard and are usually well hooked in the scissors. I am sure
that this is down to the way they are being worked. Pike have trouble targeting
jerkbaits but not so spinnerbaits, the parallel with the two soft plastic types
(slugs and grubs) is plain to see. Should you experience problems hooking pike
on large plastics fished on jigs, try adding a stinger hook, just like you would
to a spinnerbait. The stinger will have to be removed every time the plastic bait
gets chewed beyond repair, but this is not a great problem. An
alternative to the jig head is the back-weighted hook, where the weight is moulded
around the bend of the hook rather than the eye. These hooks have a what is known
as a keeper attached to their eyes, a coil of wire that the grub is screwed on
to. Once the grub is on the keeper, the hook point is put through the bait at
the appropriate place. When simply cranked back there is no difference in the
action of grubs on the two hook styles, but when paused and allowed to drop the
grubs fall slower and with a lazier tail wag on the back-weighted hooks. Swimmer
head jigs, which have a flattened profile, ride higher in the water than ball
head or stand-up jigs, and have a slight side-to-side wobble too. These jigs also
fall slower, weight for weight, somewhat like a back weighted hook. Swimmer heads
collect less weed, too, brushing it aside from the line of the hook. Not totally
weedless, but the best option without resorting to weed-guarded jigs. The bigger
the grub the better. Having done well on their six inch Mogambo Grubs I am looking
forward to getting my hands on some of Kalin's Big'Ns, real monsters at 10 inches! Another
soft plastic bait that can be fished on a jig head is the Reaper Tail. This is
also a lifeless looking creation that needs careful rigging. A slight bend should
be imparted to the bait. These lures work well hopped slowly along the bottom,
but I have also found that the small sizes, mounted on a ball-head jig, can be
worked back high in the water on a rapidly twitched retrieve which makes the tail
waggle from side to side. This catches fish, which again are usually well hooked.
Watch out for the tail catching on the hook point and the lure balling up, this
also happens with grubs on jigs and when they are used as trailers too. Soft plastics
can slip out of position on the hook or jig head, but a drop of superglue cures
that. When rigging slugs to be non-weedless, a small square of cycle inner tube
can be pushed over the hook point to keep it proud of the bait.
Reaper Tail on stand-up jig. Reaper Tail rigged horizontally on swimmer-head
jig. Renosky Super Shad on ball-head jig with wired on double hook. Unknown shad
body (cut to place hook point in correct position) on unidentified jig. Kalin's
Mogambo Grub on un-painted swimmer-head jig. 8/0 lunker City worm hook with heavy
insert weights. 9" Slug-Go rigged with point of hook just exposed. Gordon Griffiths
All Action Tail on keel-weighted keeper hook. Back-weighted keeper hook. The
opinion in the U.S. seems to be that soft plastics and jigs are at their best
in cold water conditions, worked slowly along the bottom, but I reckon they work
well enough fished high and fast in warm water. Perhaps this is because I am more
likely to be found legering a deadbait when winter comes. But maybe one winter
I will give them an extended trial. Apart from ball head jigs, I am currently
trying out Reaper Tails on stand-up and swimmer head jigs. So far the stand-up
seems to work best for a slow bottom hopping presentation, and the swimmer head
for mid-water fishing. The shape of a Reaper Tail allows for two rigging options.
I like them rigged flat on the swimmer head, and upright on the stand-up jig.
Just a personal preference. A flat-rigged reaper on a wide swimmer head can be
swum through the water with a lazy swaying action, even in very shallow water.
This set up is also quite weed resistant, owing to the up-facing hook. Rigging
Reaper Tails so they go a little way round the bend of the hook gives them a bit
more life. Not too far or they will spin on the retrieve, particularly on swimmer
heads. Don't be afraid to trim these plastics to a length that puts the hook point
in a good position. It is early days for these soft plastics, and like so much
that is radical in lure fishing I know of no U.K. suppliers for the baits or hardware
- like decent large jig heads - at present. The
one type of soft plastic bait that does seem to have gained a following in the
U.K. is the shad body. Probably because they look like fish and so don't frighten
off the conservative British lure angler! Personally, I have had little time for
these baits as I can't get them to do very much when fishing them as you might
a wobbled deadbait. I find that a natural bait actually has more action, but that
might just be me. Being fish-shaped, people tend to rig them much as they would
a deadbait for wobbling, and this is O.K. to an extent. As they come shad bodies
sink fairly slowly and have a tendency to flop on their sides when twitched. I
think this is because they are heavier at the top of the body. Perhaps a case
for insert weights along the belly of these shads. A jig head with a treble, or
trebles, attached by a length of wire overcomes the dual niggles of a lack of
stability and poor hooking. The use of a large hooked jig head gives excellent
casting with these shads, and provided the hook is positioned somewhere close
to the middle of the bait hooking is pretty reasonable too. On a jig shads perform
a little better for me. The tail has more action to my eyes, and it is simple
to work the lures deep. Equally, instead of hopping them along the bottom, they
can be ripped back in mid-water or higher. It might not look very attractive to
our eyes when fished like this, but the pike can think differently at times. For
the time being I will leave it to the likes of Del Bennett to play about with
rigs that involve threading traces through the baits. Del's had a thirty on a
plastic shad, so who am I to argue with him? Even so I shall continue to fish
them on jig heads, with or without an additional wired-in hook. I
have by no means exhausted the range of soft plastic baits that are available,
I have tried lizards and snakes (as usual for me without success!) and there are
others like the weird looking Curtis Creature which I intend to try out some time.
As you might suppose, soft plastics don't stand up too well to the attentions
of a pike's teeth. You can catch a few fish on one bait though, and unless there
is a big chunk bitten off they continue to work well. Minor cuts can be repaired
by heating the open 'wound' with flame from a cigarette lighter and then pressing
it closed while the plastic is still molten. This will prolong the life of a bait
somewhat. I have a feeling that soft plastics are going to be the next big thing
in pike lures, once there is a wide range of baits and attendant hooks and jigs
available in this country. Interest in these baits certainly seems to be growing
at the moment.
A small pike that absolutely hammered a grub fished on a back-weighted hook.
When
it comes to colours of soft plastics I have had most success with black, white,
orange and a subdued brown a little like an eel. Funnily enough this colour preference
has been across the entire range of plastics that I have tried so far. In clear
water the brown has been quite good, but so have white and orange. In murky conditions
white has scored well for me as has black. That soft plastics should work at all
in coloured water rather goes against the theory of noisy lures being the best
bet when water clarity is poor. A quieter lure than a plastic slug is hard to
imagine. When using jigs, I don't find the colour of the jig head itself to have
any bearing on matters. O.K., so it looks nicer to us if the head is painted,
maybe even in a contrasting colour to the bait, but I catch just as well on unpainted
jigs as I do on coloured ones. Care
must be exercised with storing soft plastics as they can ruin other hard plastic
baits and boxes. Leave a grub next to a plastic plug for any length of time and
the paint will have melted off the plug and maybe even the body of the lure will
have begun to melt too. Always store soft baits in plastic bags or "worm proof"
compartmented boxes. Try not to mix soft plastics of different colours in the
same bag or compartment as the colours will bleed between each lure. To keep grubs
and so on supple when stored for long periods it might be worth your while adding
a few drops of vegetable oil to the bags. Some anglers like to use a fish oil
which will soak into the baits and mask their rubbery smell and taste. Small
plastics can be fished quite successfully on the tackle you would select for spinnerbaits
or crankbaits as there is not too much demand on the gear to pull large hooks
through thick plastic bodies before contacting the pike. Bigger baits like the
nine inch Slug-Go need stouter tackle, a minimum twenty pound line and a heavy
crankbait or light jerkbait rod. Because jigs and so on can be fished through
weed beds, it is worth erring on the heavy side at times and braids of 35lb are
not out of place in snaggy situations. As a consequence the 5501 Ambassadeur is
my first choice reel matched to a rod of 6« to 7 feet, with a fairly stiff
action - particularly if big hooks gave to be struck through thick plastics. Traces
can be simple 60lb jobs fitted with the usual swivel and snap (a Duolock is easiest
to use) for fishing with jig heads, and these can be used with the smaller slugs
too. However, slugs work a little better when the trace is attached direct to
the hook, and preferably with the join sleeved in shrink tube. They were, after
all, originally designed to be fished for bass without a leader - the hook tied
direct to the main line. The weight of the trace wire can affect the action of
6 inch slugs, a heavy one making for a deeper fishing bait and twenty pound wire
being ideal for surface fishing. Varying traces can, therefore, be used to subtly
alter your lure presentation. The 9 inch Slug-Go is large enough not to be affected
too much by even a 100lb trace. Leaving
soft plastic baits, in the strictest sense, there is one, the French made Sosy,
that could have been mentioned in the crankbait chapter as it even has a lip.
It also has a segmented body made of a fairly soft plastic. The action of these
highly imitative lures is an extremely lifelike, sinuous wiggle on a steady retrieve,
and an equally convincing crippled fish imitation when worked in an erratic manner.
I have not had any success on the Sosy yet, having only just begun using them.
But I know a few who have done well on these baits. Getting
back to hard-baits, one lure type that I have not mentioned elsewhere is the vibrating
plug or rattlebait. The reason is simple. They are diabolical! I know that some
anglers rate them very highly, but I am not one of them. Most are sinkers, although
one or two floating versions are coming on the market now, and intended for smaller
species than pike. The only large rattlebait that I know of is the Bill Lewis
Super-Trap. If you think that a fast vibrating, loud rattling lure is what you
need, then give these a try. I have nothing more to say about these lures other
than to let you know of their existence. No doubt someone reading this will think
I am being unfair on these baits, and maybe one day I will change my mind. I have
one and someday I might find the place to use it and catch pike on it. Only then
will I get another. Until then I will say no more.
Pretty much the same goes for bladebaits, except that I have never used one of
these. Made from a sheet of metal with a weighted head, vibrating blades do just
that, at high frequency, when pulled through the water. The most famous model
is the Heddon Sonar, but larger pike/musky sized models are now listed in U.S.
catalogues. Like sinking rattlebaits they are at their best in deep water, and
can be either cast or jigged. I have even less to say about blade baits than I
do about rattlebaits!
A sort-of-crankbait is the Buck Perry Spoonplug. Although these are pressed out
of a single piece of sheet metal they are retrieved like crankbaits and have a
similar sort of diving, wiggling action. Hard to find and most use when fishing
deep water from a boat. A similar bait is the Russelure. I have no experience
of fishing with either of these lures either. Another lure that shares some common
ground, in as much as it is essentially a spoon, but one which fishes in a non-spoon-like
way, is the Helin Swimmerspoon. I think these lures have been deleted for some
time, but I mention them out of interest and because I know that some people have
done well on them at times - particularly when trolling. These banana-shaped spoons
actually fish with the line-tie underneath and rock from side to side. The largest
sizes sink like the proverbial stones, and are therefore best used from a boat,
which is essential if you intend to troll with them I guess! Fly
fishing for pike appears to be a growth area as I write, so I mention it here
for that reason. There have been a few anglers specialising in this for a number
of years, but for some reason more and more people are trying it out for themselves.
There is one chap locally who has had pike to over nineteen pounds on the fly.
From what I can gather he often manages to catch more on his flies than other
anglers fishing alongside him with more mainstream pike lures - which appears
to be what everyone who tries fly fishing for pike seems to find. I haven't got
round to it yet, but one of these days I will give pike-fly fishing a try, hopefully
on a trout water with some huge, previously uncaught pike in it!
Arbogast A. C. Plug, 9½". Bill Lewis Super Trap (sinking). Berkley
Power Rattle. Sosy. Helin Swimmer Spoon. Buck Perry Spoon Plug.
There are plenty of other lures around, some halfway between one type and another,
others being combination lures. Over the last few years there have appeared rattlebaits
with soft plastic back-end. Berkley do a range of these baits plus a crankbait
and a minnow too. The Berkley "Powerbait" soft plastic is even scent impregnated
to make the fish hold on longer. That's what they say anyway! These lures are
all bass-sized, but the Arbogast A.C. Plug is a large, jointed, lip-less crankbait
with a soft plastic tail pinned into the rear section. Originally designed for
bass, despite its size, the A.C. comes in three sizes from 7½ to 12 inches
in length, so it is perfectly acceptable to pike. Having a wooden body, the A.C.
Plug is very buoyant and will only run down to about two feet in the nine inch
size. For shallow water pike it works well, being good for popping, and having
a snakey wiggle when cranked. At its slowest retrieve speed the tail can be made
to slap lazily in the wake from the body, while the head wiggles just below the
surface. So far I what little success I have had has come by fishing the A.C.
pretty quickly, but steadily. I have even had pike come up to this lure when fishing
it like this over more than twelve feet of water, and not big fish either. Pike
as small as five or six pounds have shown an interest in the A.C. Plug. One interesting
incident that occurred when using this plug was that two fish that hit it (and
then fell off) actually turned and followed it in. Usually pike that hit lures
as solidly as these fish did, but don't get landed, make a hasty exit from the
scene. Perhaps this was just a one-off though. With the A.C. Plug currently selling
for around £20 I leave it to you to decide if it is worth it the money,
I remain unconvinced at present. You never know though. Leaving
aside commercially made "hybrid" lures, you can always add bits to lures in an
attempt to make them more attractive to pike. If this gives you confidence then
I am not going to say it is wrong. I have had takes on a Creek Chub Pikie fitted
with a spinner blade between the line-tie and the trace snap. But to go too far
down this road leads you away from the main point of lure fishing - catching pike.
Adorning lures for the hell of it is counter-productive in my opinion, as it very
often destroys the original behaviour of the lure, and rarely improves it. If
you want a lure to do something different - change to a different lure! Most good
baits have got the way they are by field testing of prototypes. They are how they
are for a reason. They work. Don't let me stop you experimenting though, always
try new lures, and new ways of fishing old ones. Even so, classic lures, and lure
types, will always catch pike. There is far too much over-complification talked
about in lure fishing circles by some people. And a lot of talk for talk's sake.
Pike are simple creatures, and the best lures and techniques are simple too.
|